Choosing the Right KPIs for Your Business Objectives: A Guide for Marketers

A Key Performance Indicator (KPI) is a quantifiable metric used to evaluate an organization’s success in achieving its objective. KPIs are the backbone of performance tracking, providing a clear and objective metric to measure progress, identify areas of improvement, and guide decision-making. 

However, not all KPIs are created equal. While countless metrics can be tracked, selecting KPIs tied to a specific initiative or business objective is crucial. It should possess specific, measurable, relevant, and time-bound qualities. This provides a clear and objective way to track performance and provides clarity and focus, prioritizes initiatives and resources, and fosters a culture of accountability and ownership within the organization.

How to Choose the Right KPIs for Your Business Objectives

KPI Mapping Template

Choosing the right KPIs for your business objectives is where many marketers struggle, but it’s a crucial part of achieving success. Here are some steps to help you choose the right KPIs:

Map Business Objectives to Key Drivers

The first step in identifying KPIs is understanding the business objectives. Your specific business objectives will vary depending on your company’s size and industry, as well as your growth stage. Here are a few common B2B business objectives: 

  • Increase Revenue
  • Increase Market Share
  • Decrease Cost-Per-sale
  • Penetrate New Markets

Identify Key Drivers

Once you have identified your business objectives, you can identify the key drivers that will help you achieve those objectives. Key drivers are the specific factors contributing to achieving the objective and providing a way to measure progress. 

Using the objective above of “Increase Market Share”, key drivers may include marketing branding, new customer acquisition, pricing strategy, sales and distribution, and sales channel optimizations. Not only is it common to have more than one key driver – it is ideal. Having multiple key drivers will provide you with a complete picture of the factors contributing to achieving your business objective and can help you make more informed decisions about allocating resources and improving performance toward achieving these goals.

Select the Right KPIs

Once you have identified your key drivers, you can set KPIs that will help you track your progress toward achieving the overall business objective. Remember – your KPIs must be specific, measurable, relevant, and time-bound. 

To support our objective of “Increase Market Share,” we may select “marketing branding” and “sales channel optimizations” as two of our key drivers. To convert these into KPIs that allow us to set expectations with the rest of the organization and track our progress, we might select the following as our KPIs:

  • Marketing Branding: Cost per Lead (CPL)
  • Sales Channel Optimizations: Sales Conversion Rates

A few important notes:

  • Multiple KPIs are often needed to explain the relationship and impact of key drivers on a business objective because no single KPI can provide a comprehensive understanding of performance toward achieving the objective. In the example above, website traffic could be increasing due to a flood of low-quality traffic. Without a conversion rate key driver in addition to website traffic, it would look like things were trending in the right direction.  
  • Just because it can be measured, doesn’t mean you should. Focusing on too many KPIs may mean you miss opportunities to optimize their marketing programs and drive better results. Or conversely, lead to “analysis paralysis”.

Consider the Data

When selecting your KPIs, you must consider the available data and the resources required to collect and analyze that data. KPIs are quantifiable metrics used to track progress toward achieving business objectives. To be effective, KPIs must be based on accurate and relevant data that is easily measurable and reportable. If the data used to calculate KPIs is inaccurate, incomplete, or irrelevant, it can lead to incorrect conclusions and poor decision-making.

When considering the data, ask yourselves these questions:

  • Does the data relate directly to the KPI you are measuring?
  • Is the data accurate and reliable?
  • Is the data measurable using a consistent method or tool?
  • Is the data readily available and easily accessible for analysis and reporting?
  • Is the data comprehensive and representative?
  • Is the data current and reflective of current business conditions?
  • Is the data updated and refreshed regularly to ensure it remains relevant and accurate?

If you answer no to any of these questions, you either need to take steps to address the data issue or identify a different KPI. 

Review and Refine

The last step in selecting KPIs is to regularly review and refine them to ensure they continue to provide meaningful insights into performance. If business objectives or market conditions change, KPIs may need to be adjusted to remain relevant and effective. 

This process may involve adding or removing KPIs, adjusting measurement criteria, or changing the target values. 

Prioritizing Your KPIs

After selecting the right KPIs, your next step is to prioritize them to efficiently use resources and ensure that businesses track the most critical metrics. Here is a free download of common business objectives, key drivers and KPIs – there are a lot of options! 

With so much data available, it can be challenging to determine which KPIs to focus on. Begin identifying the KPIs most closely aligned with your top business objectives. These KPIs have the most significant impact on achieving business success and should be given the highest priority. 

By prioritizing your KPIs, you can focus your resources and efforts on the most critical metrics to achieve your objectives. This helps to avoid the common pitfalls of KPI failure that many marketers face, such as information overload or spreading resources too thin.

Common Pitfalls Leading to KPI Failure

As a marketer, you likely understand the importance of being a data-driven organization and KPIs’ role in achieving that goal. KPI is a term that gets thrown around a lot, but it’s essential to go beyond just talking about them and measuring and iterating off them to drive meaningful results. Unfortunately, many businesses fall prey to common pitfalls that can lead to KPI failure. In this section, we’ll explore these common pitfalls and provide tips for avoiding them to ensure that your KPIs are aligned with your business objectives and driving long-term growth.

Lack of Alignment Between Business Objectives and KPIs

When KPIs are not aligned with business objectives, it can be challenging to demonstrate the impact of marketing programs and make progress toward business objectives. This can lead to a misallocation of resources and a lack of meaningful insights into performance. Regularly review and align your KPIs with business objectives to avoid this pitfall to ensure data-driven decisions support the overall strategy and drive business success.

Not Measuring The Right KPIs

Not measuring the right KPIs can result in missed opportunities to optimize marketing programs and drive better results. If KPIs are not providing meaningful insights into performance or are not aligned with business objectives, it can be difficult to identify areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions that support the overall strategy. To avoid this pitfall, regularly review and refine KPIs to ensure they are aligned with business objectives and provide meaningful insights into performance, allowing businesses to optimize their marketing programs and drive better results.

Focusing Exclusively on Quantity or Quality

It’s all too common for marketers to focus on either quantity of results (number of leads, website sessions, etc) or quality of results (conversion rate, engagement rate, etc) as a singular KPI . Quantity KPIs generally must be paired with quality KPIs or vice-versa  to get the full picture of performance. While some KPIs (e.g. pipeline velocity) will take both quantity and quality of results into account, most need a partner.

Focusing On Too Many KPIs

Focusing on too many KPIs can lead to a loss of focus and inefficient resource allocation. When businesses track too many KPIs, it can be challenging to determine which metrics matter most and prioritize efforts accordingly. This can result in misallocating resources and a lack of progress toward business objectives. To avoid this pitfall, businesses should focus on a few critical KPIs aligned with their objectives and regularly review and refine them to optimize resource allocation and drive meaningful results more efficiently.

Failing To Adjust KPIs Based on Changes

Failing to adjust KPIs based on changes in business objectives or marketing conditions can result in missed opportunities to optimize marketing programs and drive better results. If KPIs do not reflect changes in business objectives or market conditions, it can be difficult to identify areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions that support the overall strategy. To avoid this pitfall, regularly review and refine KPIs to ensure they are aligned with business objectives and current market conditions, providing meaningful insights into performance. 

Failure To Communicate

Failure to communicate KPIs and progress towards achieving them can lead to a lack of buy-in from stakeholders and a missed opportunity for team members to take ownership of their responsibilities and identify areas for improvement. Without clear communication, stakeholders may not fully understand the value of marketing efforts or the progress toward achieving business objectives. 

Additionally, a lack of accountability for KPIs can lead to missed opportunities for team members to take action and optimize results. To avoid these pitfalls, businesses should establish clear communication channels for KPIs, set expectations for accountability, and encourage cross-departmental collaboration to identify areas for improvement and drive better results.

Final Thoughts

The real value of KPIs lies in how efficiently they are converted into action. As the old saying goes, “what gets measured gets managed.” By focusing on the right metrics, you can ensure that your marketing and sales activities align with the company’s long-term growth objectives while remaining flexible enough to adapt to changes in internal, customer, and market dynamics. 

With the right KPIs in place, you will have a compass to navigate through the complexities of the marketing landscape. Imagine confidently communicating your marketing impact to stakeholders, backed by data-driven insights demonstrating your value. With the power of KPIs, you will optimize resource allocation, prioritize initiatives effectively, and drive meaningful results. Your marketing programs will be aligned with long-term growth objectives, positioning you as a strategic leader within your organization.

Want help in embracing the potential of KPIs to achieve your marketing goals? Brilliant Metrics can transform your journey from navigating in the dark to charting a course toward clarity, collaboration, and remarkable results. At our Marketing Strategy Workshop, we will guide you in identifying the right KPIs and creating a comprehensive marketing plan that aligns with your aspirations. Together, we will ensure that your marketing efforts drive tangible business success and set the stage for your future growth.

Get The Most From Us

Don’t miss a post! Sharing knowledge is part of what makes us special, and we take it seriously. Sign up below to continue to grow and walk up the marketing maturity curve!

Try Us On For Size

We know you’re not about to add or switch your agency on a whim. That’s why we offer a series of workshops to let you give us a spin and see what it’s like to work with us, while getting some serious value along the way.